Concrete being poured at a construction site

The Promise of Mass Timber

Why Upfront Carbon Matters

A greener grid shifts the spotlight from operational emissions to construction emissions.

Read the story

A greener grid shifts the spotlight from operational emissions to construction emissions. These emissions, often called upfront carbon, include emissions from raw material extraction, processing, transporting, and the actual onsite construction. Conventional materials can account for close to 90% of those emissions in medium-rise (8- to 18-story) buildings, but by designing with mass timber, these upfront emissions can be reduced up to 44%. And those reductions can be made today, when they matter most.

The conceptual animation illustrates how the relative importance of upfront carbon (emissions released before the building is completed) increases as the carbon intensity of the energy needed to operate a building decreases. (Based on United Nations Environment Programme’s 2020 Global Status Report and grid decarbonization targets of Oregon and Washington.)

Temporary native still — original animation pending

For a new medium-rise office building

~90%

For a new medium-rise office building (8 to 18 stories), around 90% of upfront emissions are due to the production of concrete (~75%) and steel (~15%).1

Concrete and steel (rebar) account for nearly 90% of the upfront carbon emissions in an LCA case study for an 8-story building in the Pacific Northwest.2 Mass timber construction can reduce these emissions by more than 40%.

Emissions from upfront carbon are particularly important today because they immediately add CO₂ to the atmosphere which remains there between 300 and 1,000 years.

Although the concrete and steel industries are beginning to reduce their emissions, it is a slow and challenging process. All of the upfront fossil emissions are released into the atmosphere before the building is occupied. And those emissions remain in the environment well beyond the life of the building.

01

Mass timber changes the equation

Fortunately, a lower carbon material is available today.

A mass timber medium-rise office building in the Pacific Northwest is estimated to have 30% to 44% less upfront carbon than a conventional concrete and steel design.

Carbon footprint comparison by construction type and building size

The data shown here is based on active research that directly compares the life cycle impacts of functionally equivalent mass timber and conventional concrete building designs. The study created detailed designs of three pairs of different-size (8-, 12-, and 18-story) mixed-use buildings using the Autodesk Revit building information modeling (BIM) tool. A cradle-to-gate (A1-A5) LCA was conducted on all six designs with the SimaPro software tool using Ecoinvent, Datasmart, and CORRIM databases.3

02

End-of-life and stored carbon in the building materials

What happens to the wood at the end of a building’s life is important. However, it is likely that when a building is ready for deconstruction, future policies, markets, and technology will find a better use for that carbon.

Most estimates assume that at the end of a building’s life (often assumed to be 90 years for a well-designed and constructed office building), all of the stored carbon will be released back to the atmosphere. However, reuse, down-cycling, and even deep burial can keep that carbon out of the atmosphere for much longer — even centuries.

03

Why steel and concrete are challenging to decarbonize

Both are very energy intensive and significant emitters of greenhouse gases — together totaling nearly 14% of global greenhouse gas emissions.

The two most common building materials for commercial buildings are concrete and steel. Both are very energy-intensive and significant emitters of greenhouse gases — together totaling nearly 14% of global greenhouse gas emissions.

Not only do those emissions come from burning fossil fuels for heat and electricity, but a significant amount of the emissions come from the fundamental chemistry of producing these materials. Reducing the carbon footprint of these materials is complex and challenging.

Deeper Dive

Ore to Iron and Steel

The iron and steel sector is responsible for more than 7% of global GHG emissions — mostly from the direct and indirect use of fossil fuels for heat, electricity, and processing. Steel is a metal alloy of iron (around 99%) and carbon (around 1%). Stainless steel alloys have an additional 10%+ of chromium.

Virtually all the naturally occurring iron in the crust of the earth is in the form of iron oxide (primarily Fe2O3 and Fe3O4) — basically rust. Processing iron ore into iron metal is one of the most energy- and carbon-intensive parts of the iron- and steelmaking process. And it is one of the most challenging to decarbonize.

Commercially, the oxygen in the ore is removed by using coal (essentially pure carbon) to first produce carbon monoxide (CO), and then reacting it with iron oxide to produce metallic iron and CO2. The carbon dioxide is released into the atmosphere.

Step 1

Carbon + Oxygen → Carbon monoxide

2C + O2 → 2CO

Step 2

Carbon monoxide + Iron ore → Iron + Carbon dioxide

Fe2O3 + 3CO → 2Fe + 3CO2

Since virtually all the carbon is fossil coal, the CO2 is also a GHG. However, biogenic carbon in the form of charcoal can be used. This is how iron was historically produced, including iron smelted in Lake Oswego, Oregon, in the second half of the 1800s. If the charcoal is sustainably produced, the resulting CO2 is considered biogenic.

Today, one of the most promising non-fossil carbon approaches is to use hydrogen gas produced by splitting water with electricity generated from non-carbon energy sources (hydro, wind, solar, and nuclear).

Step 1

Water + Energy → Hydrogen + Oxygen

2H2O + Energy → 2H2 + O2

Step 2

Hydrogen + Iron ore → Iron + Water

Fe2O3 + 3H2 → 2Fe + 3H2O

Only steam is released into the atmosphere.

This is now being tested at pre-commercial scale, but transforming the whole industry will likely be slow and expensive.

Deeper Dive

Limestone to Cement (and back again)

In 2019, approximately 7% of global CO2 emissions came from the concrete used in buildings and roads. Common concrete used in buildings is made up of 60% to 75% sand, gravel, and crushed rock (called aggregates), 7%–15% cement, with the rest made up of water and air. Making cement is the source of most of these emissions.

Calcination

Most of those emissions come from roasting limestone (calcium carbonate, CaCO3) to form the active ingredient of cement, quicklime (calcium oxide, CaO). More than half of those emissions (58%) are chemically released from the limestone as it breaks down. The rest of the emissions come from the fossil fuel needed to supply the heat and the electricity needed to grind and process it into cement powder.

About 40% of the emissions are from burning fossil fuel for heat:

Carbon + Oxygen → Carbon dioxide + Heat

C + O2 → CO2 + Heat

About 60% from calcination:

Limestone + Heat → Quicklime + Carbon dioxide

CaCO3 + Heat → CaO + CO2

Even if all the energy could come from non-carbon sources (renewables, nuclear, etc.), the total emissions would still make up more than 4% of total global CO2 emissions.

But the story is more complicated than just the initial production of cement.

Carbonation

Once the concrete is mixed, it quickly becomes solid building material. However, the cement in the concrete is still chemically active — as both quicklime (CaO) and slaked lime (Ca(OH)2). It starts reabsorbing CO2 from the air, once again becoming limestone (CaCO3) through a process called carbonation.

Slaked Lime (Calcium hydroxide) + Carbon dioxide → Limestone + Water

Ca(OH)2 + CO2 → CaCO3 + H2O

or

Quicklime + Carbon dioxide → Limestone

CaO + CO2 → CaCO3

This process is very slow and depends on how easy it is for the CO2 to penetrate the concrete. This is an active area of research, but many studies suggest that even after half a century, only a relatively small portion of the cement has been converted back to limestone.

However, at the end of the concrete’s useful life, it can be broken up and ground into a powder where it can much more rapidly absorb CO2. Once the chemical process is complete, the CO2 chemically released during its production will be reabsorbed. The CO2 from burning fossil fuel will not.